Getting feedback from other makers and general posters is a good way to hone in your skills as a graphics artist. Post your work in here and get opinions on how to make your work better.

Thoughts on this one:

C&c plz....




v2:

im not a big fan of this one

Added v2

i like the logo in the background, but i dont like the color scheme

c&c please....

i would like but he didnt even play in the all star game, he had to drop out. plus, i can barely see jermaine, if you could bring his iomage forward a lil bit so he is more visible, i think it'd be good

I think everything is good w/ it w/ the exception of two things:

-The "Jermaine O'neal" text should be moved elsewhere...maybe above the line or below it and maybe even a different font...

-The scan lines should have a lower opcity...My eyes are drawn too much to them...

Any thoughts on the George Steinbrenner sig below?

Good sig. 2 things I've never been a fan of.

1. - pop-out sigs. Just dont like 'em.

2. - Too many >>>>>>>>>>>\\\\\\\\\\\\ Like my scanlines, I think it draws my attention to them too much.

I make a lot of pop-out sigs :lol: It allows me to make something bigger but still keep the size that a sig should be...

You're right about the >>>>>>>'s I think I'll take em out when I get a chance...

c&c plz.....

c&c....

I think the Redskins logo in the Arrington v2 pic could stand to be a little smaller, so it's easier to tell what it is. At first I thought it was a shadow.

my first sig ever



Version 2

Considering it was a first, I like it. Overall it's a little plain. The same text in maybe a different font and with a background and it would be very nice.

which do you prefer though?

im probably gonna edit it but which should i edit?

V1 or V2?

Not bad for a first timer. A little color would be nice, but not a bad start.

what colors should i make it? i felt the black and white kind of fit the quote. but i dont really like the solid black background

I like v2 better. I'd try and keep the picture in black/white but with a better BG. Not necessarily real colorful, but with something other than plain black. Play with it and see what you can come up with.

how's V3?
Any better?
How could I improve it?

here's one I made recently, comment please

Not bad. You definitely seem to be getting better at this. Maybe I'll ask if you can do a sig for me sometime soon. But ya gotta keep improving. :pimp:

Can I get some feedback on this?

I really like it, no compliants.

pretty sweet, nice work

I don't know why this was unpinned but I'd like some feedback on this sig.

That sig is alright. Player effect is sweet. The bg is pretty cool too. The text is hard to read tho. Plus the Matt Leinhart text doesnt flow well with the rest of the sig.

I'll just throw this out there that that saying is perfect, very intelligent.

I cant even read it, does it say whinning or winning.

Winning, lol. Yea the text wasn't that good.

Ah, good, cause I like Leinart. And since it says winning I think its an awesome sig!

Some feedback on my current sig please.

The background is pretty ugly on some of them imo, no offense. Some of the text I can't even read too. Plus you should give the player an effect so it doesn't look so plain. The logos are good though.

Text is a little sloppy on a few, but other than that it's sick as hell. :D

A cheap trick sig i made for another board im on.

why do you use grunge text every time?

i think the txt in the background needs to be cleared up a lil bit and the contrast between the people and the back is grainy lookin

Because I like how it looks.

I like it as well. :P