Was It Disappointing?, what do u think... *spoilers*

[asianperson]

In my opinion, this one was really boring in the beginning and middle. I only like the end part.

whenever i read the second one, i start in the chapter when alice shows up cuz things actually start happening!

This post has been edited by Crimson Passion on Jul 28 2008, 11:32 AM

[Crimson Passion]

You must be so in love with ed, you dont like thinkin of all the pain he caused Bella

I really like this book because we get to know a lot more about Jacob and see a different side of Bella. Its great to read when I want to cry too.

[asianperson]

Yeah, maybe...

but i just think that it was too much talkin' about jake and bella, and i find it boring.

[Crimson Passion]

I loved the Jake and Bella parts. He showed her how to live again, its so sweet =)

[asianperson]

Yeah, u r right about that....but i still prefer bella with edward.

[Savannahbobanna]

I am a total Edward love love lover

and a very big Jacob... disliker


But


New Moon is my favorite. I don't know what it is about that book, but it's so amazing. My favorite one, hands down.

[asianperson]

that is confusing....if u like edward more than jacob, and New Moon is like all about jake, why do u like the second one best?

[Savannahbobanna]

There is so much... so much emotion!

I don't know how to say it other than that. I think Stephenie Meyer really did a good job on that part.

You could feel the hurt that Bella felt, you could feel the rejection, the EVERYTHING!

[asianperson]

Yes, yes. that is true.

but since all of that emotion was focused on jake, i really don't like this book as much as the others.

[Savannahbobanna]

I like any emotion. Any book that makes me actually cry, I end up totally loving it.

I think it's amazing that people can write like that, so I respect the book, I guess you could say lol.

[asianperson]

too much focus on jake for me tho.

i much prefer edward.

[Rien]

Y'all are sooo anti Jacob!! This is my fav out of them all, the saddest, the happiest at times, but the best for sure. It covers all bases very well and it give edward some compitition!!

[Emmett's Little Sis!]

I agree, people take the hjating Jake this way to far.
New Moon is my fav because it allows all of the carecters to grow more, we wouldn't have gotten the best of Eclipse if we didn't have New moon. it sets the stage.

[Gwen]

I thought this book was pretty good. I didn't think it was disappointing, really. But I like Twilight better. I like the books in chronological order actually. First Twilight, then New Moon and lastly Eclipse. I really liked the wolf pack as well. I think that was my favorite aspect of this book aside from the Volturi scene and the end in the Cullen house. Stephenie Meyer, I thought, did a pretty good job at describing Bella's emotions which this book was filled with.
I love Jacob. Really, I do. Almost as much as I love Edward. Jacob has as great personality and he's funny. I love the whole motorcycle thing because I would love one myself. He's such a great friend to Bella and he helped her so much in her time of need. That's why I understood what Bella meant in Eclipse that she should be there for Jacob. I really don't understand why anyone should hate him. I mean he is annoying at times when he's all pushy, but he's sixteen and in love. But of course everyone is entitled to their own opinions so that's ok.

[Savannahbobanna]

All people have different views and... I would hate to say it, but morals, so Jacob can seem more offensive to some people. So yes, there are some reasons people can hate him.

Not saying I hate him, he is just... annoying.

I think the wolf pack is interesting. I don't really love them, but they are fun to learn about.